I get it.

Robot Chicken with Sonic and Mario sprites.
Clever. Poorly executed.
There was a tad bit too much slapstick. Also, it was noisy. Sometimes to the point where it was annoying, you know what I mean? Shrill screams and 8bit explosion sounds out of nowhere.
You obviously put some good work into this, and the idea is very unique so I'm hoping that you improve upon the idea in the future and/or someone else takes the idea and improves upon it.

Shame.

It kind of sucks that this flash had to go the direction it went.
1 point for the awesome opening, that had me thinking good things were on the way.
1 extra point for The Cool Kids.
Other than that, terrible graphics and no real point.
You could have done much better with this...idea...
...whatever it was.

Very well done.

Beautiful piece, my friend.
Most of the score goes to the music, which I think fit brilliantly,
however the art direction was also fantastic.
Not to mention, you used your brief amount of time to make the point very clear.
Good work.

Not bad.

This is an idea you could really build on.
First of all, maybe you could have the levels be a little more interesting than just black and white, ya know? Have actually nice looking backgrounds and level themes.
Also, including medals and upgrades wouldn't hurt.
The game was fun for a while. I liked the idea a lot.

Masterpiece

I will admit, I never played the first game. But I get the idea.
Point and click adventures can either be done very right or very wrong.
Needless to say, yours was done very right.
It was challenging, but not SO challenging that it drove me crazy.
The environments were gorgeous. I mean, seriously. The art in this is top notch.
All of the characters and areas were so quirky.
Not to mention the storyline was actually very well planned out.
Amazing job. If I could give you 11 stars, I would.

I must have missed something.

It was a great idea, but at times I just kind of felt like I wasn't accomplishing anything. The enemies weren't difficult enough, and it would have been a lot more fun with upgrades. Also, I know the graphics were purposely old school and pixelated, but it was just a huge turn off for me.
I'm giving it a 7 because it was obviously NOT a bad game judging by the other scores. I must have just missed something.

Boss Battle Vibes

Very cool. I can picture this being played in like...the FINAL boss battle of an RPG. I'm getting good vibes.